A Tale of Two Secularisms

From the Boston Review, Nicholas Schmidle on the “Islamist challenge to secular Bangladesh”:

Islamist parties have multiplied over the past decade and public support for them has grown. Yet Bangladeshi society remains overwhelmingly secular, even militantly secular. And while the Islamists have grabbed headlines, the secularists are holding their own in an intense power struggle. Bangladesh has a long history of civil activism, and people are passionate and eager to voice their opinions in the streets. The secularists may not have the finances and weapons that the Islamist groups have access to. But the same leaders who fought against the imposition of Islamic politics in the Liberation War of 1971 are not about to hand the country over to men like Mufti Shahidul Islam. And he knows it.

Full Article.

Is this is another American alarmist tale of impending Islamist takeover of a third world Muslim country and a client state of the USA or a robust and sincere defence of secularism?

Perhaps Mr Schmidle should be looking at the state of secularism in his own country (USA) before lamenting the plight of secularists in Bangladesh. This is John Gray from Black Mass [2007] on secularism USA-style:

Like some other European countries Britain has an established Church; but organised religion has far less political influence than in the supposedly secular United States. The contrast is not only with the post-Christian countries of Europe but also with some Muslim countries. Judged by almost any standard the US is a less secular country than Turkey. In no other highly industrialized country is there widespread popular belief in Satan or a powerful movement contesting Darwinian theory. Nowhere else does a large segment of the population believe that the events of 9/11 were predicted in the Bible, as did a quarter of Americans polled in 2002. There is no other advanced country of which it could be observed that a theological dispute between pre-millenial and post-millenial Christians has ‘had profound implications for [American] politics’

There is another fundamentalism Schmidle discovers in Bangladesh:

Bhuiyan, a gentle-seeming middle-aged man with dark skin and a grey beard, represents a growing class of militant secularists. Many of them are former socialists or communists who have refashioned their ideology to oppose everything that the Islamists stand for. Bhuiyan told me, “I know you shouldn’t kill other humans, but these Islamic fundamentalists are like wild dogs. The Islamists have been destroying our values since 1971. They killed our golden sons in the last days before liberation.” I had met Bhuiyan about a year earlier in Karachi at the World Social Forum. On one of my first nights in Dhaka he brought me to the office of his organization, the Revolutionary Unity Front. The electricity was out and a single candle splashed light on a poster of Chairman Mao hanging on one wall and a framed photograph of Lenin on another.

I asked Bhuiyan how he viewed the contest of ideologies in modern Bangladesh. “There is only one -ism,” he replied. “That’s Marxism. When it joins with Bengalism—and it will—there will be a great revolution in Bangladesh.” His neck jerked and he ran his hands through his long, silver hair. “But first, if I had the money, I would train a brigade of people in India and return to kill all the Islamic fundamentalists in Bangladesh.”

31 Responses to “A Tale of Two Secularisms”

  1. Buy ambien overnight mail md consultation. Says:

    Buy ambien….

    Buy ambien without a prescription….

  2. Tramadol. Says:

    Ultram tramadol….

    What is tramadol used for. Tramadol. Cheapest tramadol available online. Tramadol 180 electronic check….

  3. Generic fioricet. Says:

    Generic fioricet online….

    Generic fioricet low prices amp fast delivery. Generic fioricet. Generic fioricet online….

  4. Buy generic soma. Says:

    Buy generic soma….

    Buy generic soma….

  5. Ambien cr. Says:

    Where can i buy ambien for next day delivery….

    Ambien sleeping pill. Ambien. Ambien overnight….

  6. Tramadol. Says:


    Tramadol hcl. Tramadol….

  7. Herbal phentermine. Says:


    Cheap phentermine. Mg buy phentermine. How does phentermine work. Buying phentermine. Order phentermine phentermine online….

  8. Soma. Says:

    Ashes of soma lyrics….

    Soma. Soma in urine….

  9. Tramadol. Says:


    Tramadol withdraw….

  10. Cialis online buy cheap pharmacy now lowest price. Says:

    Cheap cialis online order cialis now with discount….

    Link buy cialis cheap. Cheap cialis online order cialis now with discount. Cheap cialis….

  11. Buy valium. Says:


    Valium 5mg how long in system. Roche valium for sale. Buy valium. Online valium. Crush valium to inject. Mexian valium. Valium….

  12. Order ultram. Says:

    Ultram er….

    Ultram. Ultram 20 mg. Ultram and withdrawal. Can you buy ultram in mexico. Buy ultram from discount store. Ultram pain reliever. Ultram addiction….

  13. Ultram for long term chronic pain. Says:

    Ultram and tylenol 3 with cod….

    Ultram. Ultram online no prescription ship to florida. Buy ultram cheapest site. Ultram side effects….

  14. Tramadol hcl 50mg. Says:

    Tramadol maintence….

    Tramadol sr 100….

  15. Soma. Says:

    Tempra soma….

    Pictures of soma 750 mg.. Cheap soma. Aura soma products. Soma. Psyche and soma operate as a duality. Soma ironman. Soma san diego….

  16. Phentermine no prescription. Says:

    Xenical hgh phentermine quit smoking….

    Phentermine prozac. Phentermine. Phentermine free shipping. Danger of phentermine. Phentermine forum….

  17. Extracting pseudo ephedrine from tablets. Says:

    Sell ephedrine….

    Ephedrine. Danger of ephedrine ephedrine hci. Ephedrine hcl michigan. Biotek ephedrine. Ephedrine and pregnancy. Difference between pseudoephedrine ephedrine….

  18. Percocet. Says:

    Percocet 7.5….

    Percocet 10mg side effects. Canadian prescritions and percocet. Effects of long term percocet use. Percocet without a prescription cheap. Long term use of percocet. Percocet. Percocet 93-490 10 mg. How do i get off percocet….

  19. Cialis generic. Says:

    Generic cialis….

    Generic cialis. Generic cialis pay by money order. Cheapest generic cialis….

  20. Ultram abuse. Says:


    Information on ultram er….

  21. dfiyvor puzrxynjc Says:

    btfm emsjkur mwptuv ylvnd xdjr nagip btdlqu

  22. No prescription phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine cheap no prescription….

    Cheap no prescription phentermine. Phentermine no prescription….

  23. Ultram. Says:



  24. Halo Says:

    chris mccandless pics
    <a href= h

  25. abik zdnb Says:

    oyqukwp klzogdhqy qdsmc wlpmuf jvotwlb lrqyxtnh bwszfkj

  26. Sujoy Says:

    That IS progress. Your blogging skills are getting better and better. I had a great time reading this post.

  27. Greg Says:

    this is the coolest place ever! After visiting all kinds of sites, I figured out that this one is the most interesting

  28. Sqfrsnu Says:



  29. I found acomplia rimonabant pills Says:

    I found acomplia rimonabant pills…

    Acomplia Rimonabant Weight Loss….

  30. Free classifieds in meridia mexico Says:

    Free classifieds in meridia mexico…

    Does Meridia Work. Meridia Side Effects. Meridia Coupon. Meridia No Rx. Meridia Safety. Meridia Discussion….

  31. Generic prevacid online Says:

    Generic prevacid online…

    Cheap Prevacid….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Under the golmal, the serious golmal