Inclusive by Choice, Defensive by Nature

Perusing Amardeep Singh’s superb weblog, I found this write-up of a moving and illuminating essay posted on the Kafila blog by the writer and activist, Mahmood Farooqui - Walled away in faith’s defence.

Farooqui writes about a number of intertwining paradoxes: a secular, atheist Muslim living in a conservative Muslim mohalla (neighbourhood) of Delhi, the problem of minority belonging and the self-hatred that comes from being the ‘other’ in your own land, and the conditioning that forces Muslims to be defensive about their place in history and society.

Let me explain my locus. I am an atheist, I follow none of the Islamic taboos, but I live in a locality in the capital that can only be called a ghetto. I lived here for five years, when I was a student, when I was very self-consciously opposed to the Indian Muslim stereotype. I had grown up on Chandamama and Nandan, Holi was my favourite festival, Karna my hero, Shiva the great God, Hinduism a highly tolerant religion and I had dreams of attaining martyrdom fighting Pakistan. I was studying history and detested medieval Muslim rulers; I would expatiate on the reasons why Islam had trouble with modernity; I admired Naipaul and Rushdie; supported Mushirul Hasan during the Satanic Verses controversy — a novel I deeply admire in spite of its undoubted blasphemies — and I detested many things about Indian Muslims, except, predictably, Urdu literature and Sufism. I was, in short, a model Hinduised-Indian-Muslim, who always put India before Islam. I was desperate to leave Okhla.

But in opposition to the antagonism he feels coming from the mainstream, there are the loyalties towards his Muslim-ness that are Pavlovian in nature:

More than this, however, my views, in conformity with the rest of the academic world, about the virtues of egalitarianism, liberty and a democratic welfare state are now far less uncomplicated than they were in my youth. I still search for vestiges of the narrative of liberty in Islamic pasts, I continue to valourise streams of pluralism in Muslim sultanates and extol those Indian Muslims of the past who were ecumenical and tolerant. I would still challenge descriptions of the medieval past that underline forced conversions or bemoan the second-class treatment of Hindus. If I do not have much truck with Islam, why then do I continue to search for narratives of tolerance in the Islamic past? Why do I smart when Vajpayee says that there is trouble and violence wherever Muslims live? Why is my attitude to Islam so defensive?

Farooqui manages to pinpoint the perplexities felt by Muslims or at least those keenly felt by the more reflexive amongst us. In fact, he might as well have written an essay on the roots of the South Asian Muslim condition here, I know that for a fact.

I am eager to tell the world that Muslims of the past were different, as they indeed were, but the hidden presumption is that the current Indian Muslims are a fallen lot, in need of reform. We are not entirely sure whether it is they or Islam itself that needs reform, but we are absolutely certain that reform is needed. The West is reformation itself, Christianity has been protestantised, Hinduism has been reformed by the State, but Islam we have been trying to reform for the last 150 years and have been on the defensive for as long as well.

There are no answers to these presumptions offered by Farooqui, only insights into the paradoxes. But insight is the rarest commodity amongst Muslims today. His article should really be read in full.

121 Responses to “Inclusive by Choice, Defensive by Nature”

  1. Car Loan Says:

    Inclusive by Choice, Defensive by Nature should be interesting occurrence since you performed stunningly thanks for the info!

  2. Phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine prescription online….

    Discount phentermine. Phentermine price. Phentermine. Adipex phentermine vs….

  3. Soma. Says:

    Soma radio….

    Soma without prescription. Soma without rx. Effects of soma. Soma triathlon. Soma. Addiction to soma….

  4. Soma without rx. Says:

    Cheapest soma….

    Soma to florida. Soma triathlon. Soma. Addiction to soma….

  5. Buy cheap xanax without prescription. Says:

    Buy xanax….

    Xanax overdose. Buy xanax online. Psyweb xanax. Pharmacy order generic xanax. Xanax. Xanax with klonopin….

  6. Ambien and the menstrual cycle. Says:

    Ambien cr color….

    Ambien tolerance. Ambien. Ambien and the menstrual cycle. Ambien overnight. Long term ambien. Ambien cr….

  7. Percocet purchase online. Says:

    Purchase percocet….

    Purchase percocet. Percocet purchase online….

  8. Cheap phentermine. Says:

    Buy cheap phentermine mg tabs lowest prices….

    Cheap phentermine online without a prescription. Cheap phentermine. Buy cheap online phentermine. Phentermine cheap. Buy phentermine online buy cheap phentermine index. Cheap phentermine without. Buy cheap phentermine fre….

  9. Order phentermine uk. Says:

    Order phentermine….

    Order phentermine online uk. Order phentermine. Order phentermine online home. Order phentermine phentermine online….

  10. Cialis best price buy online. Says:

    Asprin and cialis….

    Taking viagra with cialis. Cialis with viagra….

  11. Soma. Says:

    Fatal dose of soma carisopradol….

    Soma cube. Soma. Soma ironman….

  12. Cheap tramadol. Says:

    Cheap tramadol….

    Cheap tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online. Cheap tramadol fedex overnight….

  13. Phentermine no prescription. Says:

    Phentermine no prescription free shipping….

    Phentermine 37.5 mg online prescription. Phentermine without prescription. Phentermine prescription online. Phentermine prescription. Phentermine no prescription. Buy phentermine no prescription….

  14. Soma to florida. Says:

    Soma next day delievery….

    Soma radio. Soma juice. Drug soma….

  15. Side effects tramadol. Says:

    Cheapest tramadol available online….

    Comparative potencies of opioids tramadol. Buy tramadol. Tramadol….

  16. Online ambien cheap. Says:

    Cheap ambien….

    Ambien cheap. Cheap ambien. Online ambien cheap….

  17. Paxil withdrawal. Says:

    Can you take paxil and wellbutrin together….


  18. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol hydrochloride….


  19. Debates on ritalin. Says:


    Ritalin online. Long-term side effects of ritalin. Narcolepsy and ritalin. Ritalin adult depression. Cod oil vs ritalin. Slang names for ritalin. Why is ritalin over prescribed for adhd. Ritalin la….

  20. Cheap percocet. Says:

    Gereric names for percocet 5 325….

    Percocet 10mg side effects. Percocet. Percocet vs vicodon. How long is percocet in your system….

  21. Weightloss Says:

    I was searching for \’Buy Cheap Online Pharmacy Phentermine\’ at google and got this your post (\’Inclusive by Choice, Defensive by Nature\’) in search results. Not very relevant result, but still interesting to read :)

  22. Weightloss Says:

    I was searching for \’Cheap Pharmacy Phentermine\’ at google and got this your post (\’Inclusive by Choice, Defensive by Nature\’) in search results. Not very relevant result, but still interesting to read :)

  23. Effects of soma. Says:

    Soma online sales….

    Soma next day. Soma side effects. Soma online sales. Soma to florida. Buy soma online. Soma without prescription 180 count. Soma buy soma cheap soma soma online. Drug soma cause any sexual side effects….

  24. Fioricet. Says:


    Fioricet. Fioricet free shipping. Fioricet cod….

  25. Phentermine phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine no prescription….

    Discount phentermine. Phentermine info. Phentermine….

  26. Xanax. Says:

    Buy xanax online….

    Xanax 2mg no prescription. Order xanax online. Xanax. Xanax xr. When was xanax created. Xanax side effects. Generic xanax….

  27. Buy ambien. Says:

    Ambien cr….

    Ambien with alcohol. Ambien. Ambien online. What color is ambien. Ambien overnight. Ambien safety profile. What is ambien….

  28. saver server power Says:

    saver cost power plans saver power

  29. Fioricet. Says:


    Fioricet. Cheap fioricet….

  30. pharmacy purchasing mexican Says:

    mexican pharmacy prices pharmacy + mexican

  31. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol cod….

    Buy tramadol. Tramadol side effects. Tramadol hcl. Tramadol. Tramadol ultam. Cheap comment message preview tramadol….

  32. Order tramadol. Says:

    Brand ultram order ultram tramadol pain medicine….

    Brand ultram order ultram tramadol pain medicine. Phendimetrazine order phentermine adipex tramadol. Order tramadol….

  33. Phentermine online. Says:


    Phentermine. Buy phentermine online….

  34. Ultram. Says:

    Ultram er….

    Ultram. Low dose naltrexone with ultram. Generic ultram. Ultram ortho mcneil….

  35. Tramadol. Says:


    Tramadol hydrochloride. Tramadol….

  36. Ambien and brain injuries. Says:


    Cheaper ambien prescription….

  37. Tramadol side effects. Says:


    Drug encyclopedia cor 127 tramadol. Tramadol….

  38. Buy ultram. Says:


    Ultram. Can you use low dose naltrexone and ultram. Buy ultram cheapest site. Buy ultram….

  39. Ultram addiction. Says:

    Ultram addiction….

    Ultram. Ultram ortho mcneil….

  40. Ephedra for sale. Says:

    Trim spa with ephedra….

    Products containing ephedra. Ephedra attorneys california. Purchase ephedra online. Ephedra yellow bullets. Hartford ephedra lawyers. Ephedra….

  41. Tramadol hcl. Says:

    Tramadol hcl….

    Tramadol hcl. Tramadol hcl 50 mg tablet….

  42. Phentermine without a prescription. Says:

    Phentermine prescription….

    Phentermine without prescription. Phentermine online no prescription. Phentermine prescription. Phentermine no prescription needed. Top 10 sites for prescription phentermine….

  43. Phentermine online buy phentermine online cheap. Says:

    Buy phentermine online….

    Buy phentermine online without prescription cheap. Phentermine mg buy phentermine mg tablets online….

  44. Jayne Says:

    My first internet- experience was not successful. But anyway I keep posting from time to time. All information online is for people to discuss. I think this is the most important thing why internet is so popular everywhere

  45. Generic xanax 2 mg no prescription. Says:

    Generic lortab xanax this….

    Cheap generic 2mg xanax. Generic xanax 2 mg no prescription. Generic lortab xanax this. Generic xanax. No prescription xanax generic….

  46. Purchase ultram. Says:

    Purchase ultram….

    Purchase ultram….

  47. Tramadol cheap no rx free overnight shipping. Says:

    Tramadol cheap no rx free from india….

    Cheap tramadol….

  48. Buy phentermine online no prescription. Says:

    Phentermine no prescription….

    Phentermine no prescription….

  49. Ambien purchase omline. Says:

    Ambien side effects….

    Ambien. Long term ambien. Ambien cr. Ambien no prescription needed….

  50. Ambien cr. Says:

    Will ambien show up in a urine test….

    Ambien cr….

  51. Herbal viagra. Says:

    Herbal viagra….

    Herbal viagra testing amsterdam. Herbal man com viagra woman. Viagra herbal alternatives. Herbal viagra….

  52. Discount phentermine. Says:

    Discount online phentermine….

    Discount phentermine….

  53. Cod tramadol overnight cheap. Says:

    Cheap tramadol….

    Cheap tramadol….

  54. skinnydog Says:

    Fortunately it amuses as before…………….I’m trying to keep away from reading posts like this. It is totally meaningless. Ain’t it shame to post rubbish like this?

  55. Pillinc buy phentermine adipex meridia online. Says:

    Buy phentermine….

    Buy phentermine online….

  56. reqlfg uphw Says:

    dbxiev mqerznj pwqxjz vtiho tzir nkacptm bcqaouyv

  57. Tramadol cod. Says:

    Tramadol cod….

    Tramadol cod. Tramadol cheap cod….

  58. Ambien cr. Says:

    Ambien cr….

    Ambien cr effects. Ambien cr. Ambien cr side effects….

  59. Hysbysfwrdd cymrux xanax cheap phentermine. Says:

    Hysbysfwrdd cymrux xanax cheap phentermine….

    Xanax drug test. Cheap generic xanax 2mg bars. Xanax. Side effects of xanax….

  60. Phentermine 37 5mg. Says:

    Phentermine 37 5mg….

    Phentermine 37 5mg….

  61. Buy cheap soma. Says:

    Soma cubes….

    Soma without prescription. Soma. Drug soma. Soma information. Border bangers soma….

  62. Multiplication games. Says:

    Free online multiplication games….

    Math multiplication games….

  63. Cheap phentermine cod. Says:

    Phentermine cheap no prescription….

    Cheap phentermine. Cheap phentermine no prescription. Cheap phentermine cheap phentermine free shipping. Buy cheap phentermine online….

  64. Tramadol. Says:


    Buy tramadol index. Tramadol and depression. Tramadol withdraw. Tramadol….

  65. Phentermine and methamphetamine. Says:

    Phentermine and methamphetamine….

    Phentermine and methamphetamine….

  66. Clomid. Says:

    Clomid success stories….

    Clomid. Clomid fertility pill. Clomid fertility drugs. What does clomid do. Clomid success rates….

  67. No pescription required phentermine 37.5 mg. Says:

    Phentermine 37.5 mg….

    Phentermine 37.5 mg online prescription mastercard. Phentermine 37.5 mg 119.00. Best prices on phentermine 37.5 mg without rx. Phentermine 37.5 mg….

  68. Soma next day delievery. Says:

    Soma side effects….

    Soma review the retail church chris thron. Soma without rx. Pictures of soma 750 mg.. Soma muscle relaxant. Cheap soma. Soma. Buy domain onlinevcvpl soma….

  69. Cheap 37 5 phentermine. Says:

    Cheap phentermine cod….

    Cheap phentermine. Buy cheap phentermine online. Cheap phentermine online. Buy cheap phentermine. Cheap phentermine net….

  70. Xanax. Says:

    Xanax side effects….

    Xanax withdrawal symptom. Xanax cocktail. Generic xanax….

  71. Portable gps. Says:

    Portable gps tomtom….

    Gps portable. Best portable gps tracker. Portable gps….

  72. Xanax online without prescription. Says:

    Xanax online….

    Buy xanax online. No rx online xanax. Xanax online without persctiption. Order online xanax. Xanax best pharmacy online. Buy no xanax online prescription all on one site. Buying xanax online….

  73. Home loans and china. Says:

    Va home loans….

    Countrywide home loans. No doc home loans. Washington mutual home loans….

  74. Generic viagra. Says:

    Generic viagra….

    Generic viagra. Viagra generic….

  75. Xanax. Says:

    Buy xanax….

    Buy xanax. Xanax effects. Generic xanax 2 mg no prescription. Side effects of xanax….

  76. Wellbutrin. Says:

    Wellbutrin xl….

    Effexor xr and wellbutrin xl. Alcohol wellbutrin. Wellbutrin xl. Wellbutrin weaning off. Wellbutrin….

  77. Buy xanax. Says:

    Buy xanax online without a prescription….

    Buy xanax without prescription. Buy 180 xanax….

  78. Cheap cialis. Says:


    Problems lubricating even with cialis….

  79. Generic ambien. Says:

    Ambien cr….


  80. Casino classic play free games. Says:

    Free casino games….

    Play free casino games….

  81. Grand casino tunica. Says:

    Grand casino hinkley minnesota….

    Grand casino biloxi ms. Mgm grand casino in detroit. Firelake grand casino ufc….

  82. Buy 180 xanax. Says:

    Ijijiji xanax hompage….

    Xanax withdrawal symptom….

  83. Tramadol. Says:


    Buy tramadol. Tramadol hcl. Tramadol. Tramadol c.o.d delivery….

  84. Buy ambien online no prescription. Says:

    Get ambien without a prescription….

    Ambien prescription. Ambien online no prescription overnight delivery. Ambien non prescription. Buy ambien without prescription….

  85. Cheap viagra. Says:

    Cheap viagra….

    Cheap molde ticket viagra. Cheap viagra….

  86. Casino royale online viewing movie. Says:

    Online casino….

    Golden river online casino. Online casino….

  87. Soma. Says:

    Soma intimates stores….


  88. Xanax 2 milligram. Says:


    Side effects of drug xanax. Buy xanax. Xanax. Xanax xr. Ativan xanax valuim trial pack….

  89. Atlantis casino. Says:

    James bond casino royal….

    Seneca casino. Latest no deposit bonus casino coupon codes. Soaring eagle casino. Play casino games. Free casino games online. Casino arizona….

  90. Car loan calculator. Says:

    Orlando new car loan….

    New car loan illinois. Car loan calculator. Las vegas new car loan….

  91. Side effects from lipitor. Says:


    Lipitor and grapefruit. Muscle loss due to lipitor. Lipitor side effects. Lipitor….

  92. Rlwoobd Says:



  93. wmfx dfqmgwz Says:

    dcfsqy szcui wampilj dmtcilw xnwajozq wkvnqoyd awhsr

  94. Where to find xenical online Says:

    Where to find xenical online…


  95. Prozac Says:


    Prozac. Buy Prozac. Generic Prozac Online. Prozac. Order Prozac Online. Prozac Online….

  96. Nexium Says:



  97. Meridia coupon Says:

    Meridia coupon…

    Meridia. Buy Meridia Without Prescription. Information On Drug Meridia. Meridia Mexico. Meridia Diet Pills. What Is Meridia Used For….

  98. Http:// Says:


    Paxil Cr Side Effects. Paxil Made Me Do It. How To Get Off Paxil. Paxil Withdraw. Paxil Attorneys Los Angeles. An Increase In Anxiety When Starting Paxil….

  99. Aip payday loan. Says:

    Why can t i get a payday loan….

    Payday advance loan illinois. Payday loan reviews. Payday loan. Honest faxless payday loan….

  100. Craps online Says:

    Craps online….

    Craps online Craps online. Online craps no download….

  101. Http:// Says:


    Levitra Verses Cialis. Levitra Flomax Interaction. Levitra Free Samples. Levitra Commercial Clips. Levitra Weakness. Levitra And Alcohol….

  102. Student loans. Says:

    Private student loans….

    Direct student loans. Private student loans. Defaulted student loans. Student loans. Acs student loans. Quick private student loans. College student loans….

  103. Private party car loans. Says:

    Car loans….

    Car title loans about us. Pre owned car loans. Car title loans in utah….

  104. Http:// Says:


    Blue Moon Cafe Roof Tiles. How To Replace Loose Roof Tiles. Solar Roof Tiles Australia. How To Remove Concrete Roof Tiles. Rake Roof Tiles. Recycled Roof Tiles Uk….

  105. Generic zithromax online Says:

    Generic zithromax online…

    Zithromax. Cheap Zithromax. Buy Zithromax. Zithromax Online. Order Zithromax Online. Generic Zithromax Online….

  106. Hydrocodone apap. Says:

    Hydrocodone apap….

    Hydrocodone apap. Hydrocodone apap with alcohol. Hydrocodone apap 5 500. Watson hydrocodone apap. Hydrocodone apap 5mg 500mg. Prescription drug hydrocodone apap 7.5 325 tb….

  107. Ambien cr. Says:

    Ambien cr….

    Buy ambien cr. Ambien cr….

  108. Buy viagra in canada. Says:

    Buy viagra online….

    Buy viagra online. Where can i buy gneric viagra usa. Buy viagra online uk cialis levitra. Buy viagra. Viagra uk buy viagra online order viagra….

  109. Free porn movies. Says:

    Porn free….

    Free porn clips. Free mp4 porn. Free porn mpegs. Free porn videos. Free porn movie clips. Free porn….

  110. Acyclovir. Says:



  111. Zyrtec. Says:



  112. Discover credit card. Says:

    Bad credit credit card….

    Free porn no credit card. Credit card debt….

  113. Designer replica handbags. Says:

    Designer replica handbags….

    Designer replica handbags….

  114. Porn no credit card needed. Says:

    Chevron credit card….

    Free porn no credit card. Reducing credit card debt http. Chase credit card….

  115. Sex movies. Says:

    Sex movies….

    Sex movies….

  116. Paris hilton video. Says:

    Paris hilton sex tape….

    Britney spears nude paris hilton. Britney spears paris hilton. Paris hilton up skirt. Paris hilton video. Paris hilton naked. Paris hilton crotch pictures. Paris hilton….

  117. Maria sharapova nude photos. Says:

    Maria sharapova….

    Maria sharapova pictures biography posters. Fake nude pictures of maria sharapova. Maria sharapova photos. Maria sharapova porn. Maria sharapova tennis dresses….

  118. Cheap lexapro Says:

    Cheap lexapro…

    Cheap Lexapro….

  119. Landau nursing uniforms Says:

    Landau nursing uniforms…

    Landau Nursing Uniforms….

  120. Atomoxetine strattera from eli lilly. Says:

    Atomoxetine strattera from eli lilly….

    Atomoxetine. Eli lilly atomoxetine. Atomoxetine and drug abuse liability….

  121. Vestra reboxetine. Says:


    Vestra reboxetine. Reboxetine edronax. Reboxetine….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Under the golmal, the serious golmal