Seven Seas: Brick Lane redux

When the LRB published this review of Brick Lane in 2003, Sukhdev Sandhu had no way of knowing the amount of brimstone and paan-spit the book, and subsequently the making of the film, would generate.

Like one of Bangladesh’s multitudinous rivers, Sukhdev’s review is long, broad and wonderfully meandering. As a review of Brick Lane, it may be one of the most generous Monica Ali has received, but we will come to that later. This article is so much more than a book review. It is also as a beautifully observed history of Brick Lane, charting Whitechapel’s role as a half-way house to successive waves of immigrants from the Huguenots, the Jews and then to the Bengalis from the early 20th century and, most latterly, the Somalians.

Monica Ali’s book never mentions the confrontation against the National Front which the Bangladeshis of Whitechapel found themselves plunged into in the 70s and 80s.

In 1970 there was also a huge rise in the number of attacks on Bangladeshis. Seventy years earlier, Arnold White, in whose book Reaney’s anti-semitic comments appeared, had teamed up with Major Evans Gordon, the MP for Stepney and founder of the British Brothers’ League, in a campaign to restrict Jewish immigration. Successfully so: in 1905 the Government passed the first Aliens Act. Forty years after Mosley’s efforts to stir up racial tension in the area, skinhead gangs began to stalk Brick Lane, smashing windows, spitting at children, carving up the faces and backs of bystanders. At the north end, near the traditionally less tolerant area of Bethnal Green, National Front members sold their papers on market days and congregated at a pub in Cheshire Street. Soon Bengali schoolchildren were being allowed out of school early, their mothers walking to work in numbers for fear of being ambushed or pelted, and parents imposing curfews on their kids. Tower Hamlets fitted council tenants with fire-proof letterboxes.

Sandhu packs his article with passages about the grim reality of families cramped into tenements whilst fighting a full scale race war on the streets but this existence never gets picked up by Monica Ali, in spite of being an integral part of the East End Bengali narrative. Sandhu points out this gaping hole at the heart of Brick Lane:

How strange then that this novel, part of it set in 1985, has so little to say about the campaign of violence and intimidation which marked the lives of almost every Bangladeshi, young and old, male or female, who lived in and around Brick Lane before the current era of gentrification. To write about this area today or make sense of its cuspy, transitional status, one has to write about what went on before.

What went on before is something that, the novel Brick Lane does not bother itself with overmuch. But Sandhu has an explanation for this omission. It was Ali’s publishing company who repackaged a story about non-Sylhety Bangladeshis, who happended to settle in Brick Lane, into a topical, punchy book that subsequently got “treated as a direct portal into the minds of Bangladeshi East Londoners” by the Sunday papers.

It comes as no surprise to learn that Brick Lane was originally called ‘Seven Seas and Thirteen Rivers’, a title that alludes more generally to the distance between Sylhet and England; the decision to give it a snappier, more happening, less accurate title is the publisher’s.

The protesters against the Monica Ali film are regressive and reactionary, I thought so myself. But turns out they are right in one sense. The book is misrepresentation by error, but most probably an intentional error of the canny book marketing sort.

For me Sandhu has contextualised the grievances of the men who have protested against the Monica Ali book/film. It comes as a surprise to realise that these were the same men who, twenty years ago, fought another set of regressive and reactionary attitudes in the streets of Tower Hamlets.

They were the ones, together with their brothers and uncles, who took the full brunt of the assault from the 1970s to the 1990s; whose education suffered as a result of bullying classmates and unsympathetic teachers; who attended the vigils outside the Royal London Hospital waiting in vain for Quddus Ali to regain consciousness. Even the nail-bomb planted in Brick Lane by David Copeland in April 1999 didn’t check their will to reclaim the streets of Whitechapel.

Hat Tip: Zubaer

73 Responses to “Seven Seas: Brick Lane redux”

  1. terry fitzpatrick Says:

    I don’t know who has written this article but is another piece of drivel by people who, because they are Asian, seem to think that they are experts on Brick Lane. I was one of the people who organized the defence of the area in the 70’s as well being on the Benglai Housing Action Group which with a thousand members was the largest grass roots movement ever amongst Bangl;adeshis in East London. Ali’s book contains characters I recognise. It is worth remembering the reaction to the King of the Ghetto 20 years ago, the same small group of reactionaries denied that non Syhletis had been involved in leading the housing and anti fascist movements. And non of the book protesters were involved in those movements. I was. Terry Fitzpatrick

  2. Sharif Says:


    The article is probably inaccurate - I don’t know, I wasn’t there.

    I am here now though and I think Monica Ali has written Catherine Cookson with exotica - shame we can’t short list Cookson for a booker prize, too.

  3. Soma. Says:

    Akane soma….


  4. Ambien cr. Says:


    Buy ambien without a prescription. Ambien….

  5. How while on adderall xr. Says:


    Adderall coupon. Buy adderall. Freebasing adderall. Adderall prescription. Adderall. Side effects of adderall….

  6. Soma. Says:



  7. Soma to florida. Says:

    Soma cube….

    Soma prescription medicine. Soma online sales. Soma. Soma drug history. Soma san diego….

  8. Ambien. Says:

    Buy ambien without a prescription….

    Ambien us pharmacy. Ambien. Ambien online no prescription overnight delivery….

  9. Herbal phentermine. Says:

    Cheap phentermine….

    Phentermine dosage….

  10. Lowest price for phentermine. Says:


    Buy phentermine. Phentermine. Order phentermine uk. Phentermine yellow….

  11. Suicide with soma how many does it take. Says:

    Soma side effects….

    Soma cube. Soma without prescription. Crushing muscle relaxer soma. Soma next day delievery. Soma. Soma san diego….

  12. Phentermine. Says:


    Phentermine online. Phentermine info. Buy phentermine. Phentermine….

  13. Soma cube. Says:

    Watson soma….

    Chevelle soma. Soma. Soma sen. Soma medication. Soma and addiction….

  14. Soma to florida. Says:


    Soma. Buy soma online. Soma without prescription 180 count. Buy soma watson brand online 150 tablets. Watson soma. Addiction to soma. Soma and addiction….

  15. Adderall dts. Says:


    Buy adderall online. Adderall without prescription. Adderall….

  16. Danger of phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine line….

    Phentermine info. Phentermine. Adipex phentermine vs. Phentermine cheap. Phentermine prescription. Phentermine online pharmacy. Cheapest phentermine. Online phentermine….

  17. Ambien. Says:


    Ambien and memory loss. Ambien during pregnancy. Free trial version of ambien. Ambien side affects. Ambien. Ambien addiction. Cheaper ambien prescription. Ambien side effects. Drugs detected on drug test ambien….

  18. Ambien cr. Says:

    Drugs detected on drug test ambien….

    Ambien verses temacetam. Ambien. Sex ambien night….

  19. Soma. Says:

    Effects of soma….

    Soma muscle relaxer. Soma. Drug soma….

  20. Ambien dosage. Says:

    Ambien and brain injuries….

    Ambien online. Generic ambien. Ambien on line. Buy ambien….

  21. Phentermine adipex. Says:


    Phentermine online. Phentermine. Phentermine on line. Phentermine hcl. Buy phentermine on line….

  22. Online phentermine. Says:


    Phentermine online. Cheap phentermine. Phentermine….

  23. Adderall. Says:

    How while on adderall xr….

    Adderall abuse….

  24. Buy cheap phentermine. Says:

    Online phentermine….

    Phentermine online. Discount phentermine. Phentermine. Buy cheap phentermine online….

  25. Phentermine dosage. Says:


    Phentermine price. Phentermine. Phentermine without prescription. Buy phentermine mg. Buy cheap phentermine online….

  26. Half life of percocet. Says:


    Buy percocet online no prescription. Percocet….

  27. Phentermine on line. Says:

    Buy phentermine….

    Phentermine. Buy phentermine online. Phentermine overnight. Phentermine free shipping. Keyword phentermine….

  28. Ambien and side effects. Says:

    Long term ambien….

    Ambien. Generic ambien. Ambien cr addiction. Long term ambien. Drugs detected on drug test ambien. Buy ambien without prescription….

  29. Vampiress13 Says:

    Simply outstanding ^_^! I like posts like that. Your blog is added to my favorites ;-). Continue writing.

  30. JackBauer91 Says:

    Yeah!! (Wrings hands)! Nice blog you have here. I’ve enjoyed much reading your last posts. Keep it that way.

  31. Soma to florida. Says:

    Soma seeds….

    Cheap soma watson. Soma seeds. Soma. Pornstar soma. Drug soma. Soma fm….

  32. Cialis effects. Says:


    Purchase cialis….

  33. Soma muscle relaxant. Says:

    Prescription medication side effects for soma….

    Soma plant. Cheap soma. Soma online sales. Soma. Soma buy soma cheap soma soma online. Soma san diego….

  34. Percocet. Says:

    Cheap percocet….

    Compare brand name and generic percocet. Percocet withdrawal symptoms. Long term use of percocet. Fun with percocet. Percocet. Percocet shipped cod no prior….

  35. Viagra uk buy viagra online order viagra. Says:

    Buy viagra online….

    Buy viagra online. Buy cialis online viagra cialis buy cialis online. Viagra uk buy viagra online order viagra….

  36. Buy viagra. Says:

    Buy viagra….

    Buy viagra online. Buy viagra Buy viagra….

  37. Generic xanax 2 mg no prescription. Says:


    How long does xanax stay in your system. Xanax. Xanax online. Geniric xanax….

  38. Buy xanax online. Says:

    Search results xanax online….

    Generic xanax online without a prescription. Xanax online no prior perscription. Buy xanax online. Buying xanax online next delivery….

  39. Hardcore sex. Says:

    Free indian hardcore sex….

    Free sex hardcore movies. Hardcore lesbian sex. Hardcore sex….

  40. Phentermine line. Says:


    Phentermine prozac. Discount phentermine. Phentermine price. Herbal phentermine….

  41. Buy online cheap and fast tramadol. Says:

    Buy cheap tramadol at online drug store….

    Cheap tramadol. Cheap tramadol cod. Buy online cheap and fast tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol at online drug store. Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online. Cheap tramadol platinum rx. Cheap comment message preview tramadol….

  42. Can you buy xanax without a prescription. Says:

    Buy 180 xanax 2mg….

    Buy xanax. Buy xanax online. Can you buy xanax without a prescription….

  43. Ambien and memory loss. Says:

    Ambien cr color….

    Ambien latest side effects….

  44. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol withdraw….

    Best price for tramadol. Tramadol hcl. Tramadol….

  45. Order xanax bars without prescription online. Says:

    Order online xanax….

    Order xanax bars without prescription online. Order xanax without a prescription. Order xanax online. 2mg xanax order. Pharmacy order generic xanax. Order xanax canadian pharmacy. My blog order xanax mg xanax cheap xanax online….

  46. Phentermine forum. Says:

    Phentermine 37 5mg….

    Phentermine. Mg buy phentermine. Phentermine prescription. Cheapest phentermine. Phentermine information….

  47. Viagra. Says:


    Viagra. Cheap viagra. Viagra sales uk. Re viagra cello….

  48. Adderall. Says:


    Adderall coupon. What is adderall. Adderall….

  49. Instant payday loan. Says:

    Payday loan….

    Payday loan az. Payday loan reviews. Payday loan. Instant no fax payday loan. Looking for a small payday loan. Mr payday loan….

  50. bjfqlvhcy udrqmhpa Says:

    dresktln lsdzqrk dzvbs vlftgd nwifoega xwhsbycg ldgfpj

  51. Adderall. Says:


    Adderall xr side effects. Buy adderall. Buy adderall online no prescription needed. Dosage and tolerance to adderall. Adderall purchase without prescription. Adderall withdrawal. Adderall….

  52. Payday loans. Says:

    Payday loans fast….

    Payday loans online. Payday loans articles. Payday loans. No fax payday loans….

  53. Ambien cr. Says:

    Ambien cr….

    Ambien cr 12.5 photo. Can you take ambien cr with atarax. Photo of ambien cr. Buy ambien cr. Ambien cr….

  54. Coupons for soma by chicos. Says:

    Addiction to soma….

    Soma side effects. Soma. Antidote soma valium. Soma online….

  55. Cheap generic xanax 2mg bars. Says:

    Cheap generic 2mg xanax….

    Cheap xanax. Cheap xanax online buy cheap xanax buy cheap xanax. Buy cheap xanax without prescription….

  56. Tramadol cod. Says:

    Tramadol cod….

    Yorku ca view topic tramadol cod saturday delivery. Buy tramadol online cod. Tramadol 180 cod. Tramadol cod….

  57. Herbal viagra. Says:

    Herbal viagra testing amsterdam….

    Herbal viagra testing amsterdam. Herbal viagra….

  58. Generic viagra. Says:

    Soft tab generic viagra….

    Generic viagra lowest price. Generic viagra. Generic viagra american express. Generic viagra india. Discount generic viagra on line. Generic lavitra offers an alternative to viagra….

  59. Where can i buy ambien for next day delivery. Says:

    Buy ambien online no prescription….

    Buy ambien without a prescription. Buy ambien cr overnight mail md consultation. Where can i buy ambien for next day delivery. Buy ambien online. Buy ambien cr. Buy ambien….

  60. Grand casino tunica. Says:

    Grand casino….

    Grand casino hinckley. Grand casino and spa resort tunica ms. Casino grand bay sunsetters club voucher codes. Grand casino hinkley mn. Grand victoria casino bus tour….

  61. Casino. Says:

    Casino royal….

    Casino royale. Casino royal….

  62. Cheap viagra. Says:

    Untitled cheap viagra bloghoster….

    Cheap molde ticket viagra. Cheap viagra. Buy cheap viagra online uk….

  63. Soma fm. Says:

    Effects of soma….

    Soma. Soma without prescription 180 count. Soma beds….

  64. Free strip poker. Says:

    Strip poker….

    Strip poker. Strip poker rules. Strip poker videos. Free online strip poker xxx. Free nude strip poker. Free strip poker….

  65. Loans against car title. Says:

    Car loans….

    Car title loans salem oregon. Car loans. Car title loans. Gmac car loans….

  66. Free online casino games. Says:

    Play free casino games….

    Play free casino games. Free casino slot games no download. Gambling virtual casino games free. Free casino games….

  67. Federal student loans. Says:

    Student loans bad credit….

    Alternative student loans….

  68. Black jack casino roulette online gaming. Says:

    Calico film music design top online casino….

    Online casino slot tournament free. No deposit online casino. Online slot machine Owning a online casino….

  69. Loan calculator. Says:

    Business loan….

    Government loan for small business. Consolidate debt loan http. Home equity loan. Auto loan rates. Home loan lending. Auto loan. Cheap loan. Perkins loan….

  70. Anal sex clips. Says:

    Free anal sex video clips….

    Free hardcore anal sex clips. How to have anal sex video clips. Free anal sex video clips. Anal sex clips. Free anal sex movie clips. Video clips of anal sex….

  71. Zyrtec. Says:


    Zyrtec side effects. Take zyrtec and benadryl together. Zyrtec pregnancy class. Zyrtec. Zyrtec-d. Patent expiration for zyrtec….

  72. Free gay porn. Says:

    Free gay porn….

    Free gay porn….

  73. Acyclovir tab. Says:


    Acyclovir 400 mg tablets. Acyclovir….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Under the golmal, the serious golmal