Brown Man’s Burden?

Ali Eteraz is “severely hurt” by Western Muslim attitudes to Iraqi insurgency. Best let him explain his pain himself, from a post entitled Western Muslim Opinion On The War in Iraq:

I have to say, I am severely hurt by what Islam has become in Iraq. In fact, to say that this blatant murdering of civilians by the militants contains any remnants of Islam, is difficult if not impossible. The Islam of the Sunni militants is a theology of anarchy which has no respect for the rules of war, or the values of Islam. The Shi’a themselves are no less. Islam does not stand for total war, but the Sunni and Shi’a militants violate that prescription almost regularly (to the tune of thousands of murders of average Iraqi civilians). We Western Muslims can oppose the American occupation, but we also have to oppose the way the insurgents are brutalizing and defilling life and human dignity.

As someone who falls into the category of “Western Muslim” myself, I feel compelled to disagree with this nonsense. Not because the inhumanity of Iraqi insurgents doesn’t make me sick to the stomach but because Eteraz’s post is symptomatic of this widespread notion that suggests that Muslims (and Muslims specifically) who don’t oppose the sectarian violence in Iraq are a priori supporters of insurgents because they are “anti-USA” or are hardwired to view the conflict in terms of the oldest Islamic internecine dispute of them all: Sunni vs Shi’a.

There are other Muslim “readings” of the insurgency out there, believe it or not. A far more mature and reasoned ‘warts and all’ explanation of the insurgency and the sectarianism which begets it, which we now call “Civil war in Iraq”, can be found in this post by Mash of OHILTSW. Another Western Muslim, who, whilst he’s at it, does a good job of avoiding the silly strawman trap set by Eteraz:

The killing in Iraq right now has very little to do with “resistance” to the occupier. The killing of Shia by Sunnis is not meant to drive the Americans out of Iraq. The American presence in Iraq currently is almost irrelevant. The American invasion and occupation was the catalyst for the civil war, and to that end, it has succeeded spectacularly in destroying civil society in Iraq.

There are a number of conflicts going on in Iraq. There is first the sectarian civil war between the Shia and Sunni Arab communities. There is the struggle for Kirkuk taking place between the Iraqi Arabs and the Kurds (this in many ways is the most intractable of the conflicts facing Iraq). There is a fight emerging between the multiple factions within the Shia community - this is the bloody struggle between the Sadrists and the SCIRI. The government of al Maliki will be a casualty of the battle within the Shia community. There is an Iraqi nationalist insurgency going on against the Americans. And lastly, there is a battle between foreign Islamists and the American forces in Iraq. So, when Iraqis butcher Iraqi, they are settling their own scores - they are not killing Iraqis to expel the Americans. Only people like Dick Cheney in their narcissistic existence believe that Iraqis kill each other because they don’t like him or his boss.

[…]

So, in modern day Iraq, the fight between the Shia and the Sunni once again is over political power. To put it crudely, the dispute is over which tribe should rule Iraq after Saddam Hussein. The unresolved tribal dispute that has its origins in Islamic history, continues to rage in Iraq now that civil society has collapsed. In this fight, George W Bush’s “War on Terror” is irrelevant.

75 Responses to “Brown Man’s Burden?”

  1. Zeeshan Says:

    Nice one. I tire of people lamenting “the state of Islam” with respect to one or another messy political situation, without first looking at the underlying politics. It smacks of intellectual laziness.

  2. Chris Says:

    I’m not a Muslim, and I am generally critical of both my countries (USA) involvment in the Middle East and of the Arab pennisula’s inability to figure out what’s going on. This comment however is right on the money, the Western News agencies are painting a picture that simply is not true, when the british drew up lines in Araba they drew them through tribal territories. Europeans are only smug because there wasn’t 24 hours news broadcasting there disputes (using both chemical warfare and genocide). This conflicts generally peter out when natural barriars arise and the general communty gets tired of bloodshed. That being said I am very sorry for my countries roel in bringing this about and pray that Muslims will be ables to grant the average American a level of for forgiveness.

    Chris

  3. M'Eddie Says:

    Thanks for pointing me to Marsh’s article. I was looking for and appreciated the nuanced analysis he brought to the conflictS in Iraq. One quibble I would have with him is the suggestion that the ‘debaathification” resulted in the destruction of Iraqi civil society. The removal of the Baathists merely allowed the conflicts seething beneath under Sadam’s repression to rise to the fore; its not as if there was any cohesive civil society then. Much like intrastate conflicts breaking out after the Cold War, centrist controlled regimes could only control civil conflicts, not quell them. Their resolution, unfortunately, requires clear winners, or a feat of collective humanitarian enlightenment that is currently beyond the Iraqis, or the Americans, or any of the so-called Coalition of Willing or Unwilling..

    Wassaaap Faisal Bhai! Happy New Year to you and all who read your Blog.

  4. Soma muscle relaxant. Says:

    Pornstar soma….

    Soma without rx 180 count. Soma online sales. Soma. Soma half ironman. Suicide with soma how many does it take. Ashes of soma lyrics. Soma family apartments san francisco. Akane soma….

  5. Ultram. Says:

    Ultram doses….

    Ultram. Ultram in mexico. Ultram er. Buy ultram cheapest site. Ultram withdrawl. Ultram ortho mcneil….

  6. Xanax 2mg. Says:

    Xanax lawsuits….

    Xanax overdose….

  7. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Comparative potencies of opioids tramadol. Tramadol dog. Tramadol. How much tramadol for daily use for dogs. Side effects tramadol….

  8. Diazepam to lorazepam conversion. Says:

    Lorazepam….

    Prostate cancer lorazepam. Lorazepam. Lorazepam 0.5mg….

  9. Generic ambien. Says:

    Generic ambien….

    Generic ambien. Generic ambien available. Ambien generic medication. What is the generic name for ambien….

  10. Buy cod ambien. Says:

    Where can i buy ambien for next day delivery….

    Ambien buy. Buy ambien with a discount at leading pharmacy. Ambien cr buy online no rx….

  11. Tramadol no prescription. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Ratio of tramadol. Tramadol. Buy cheap tramadol mg tablets only in us online. Cheapest tramadol available online….

  12. Soma online sales. Says:

    Drug soma….

    Soma. Soma buy soma cheap soma soma online. Drug soma cause any sexual side effects. Suicide with soma….

  13. Generic soma. Says:

    Generic soma….

    Generic soma. Generic soma soma generic. What does generic soma look like….

  14. Paxil and weight gain. Says:

    Paxil and weight gain….

    Paxil and weight gain. Why do people gain weight on paxil. Paxil weight gain….

  15. Ultram. Says:

    Buy ultram pharmacy online….

    Ultram tramadol. The mondego group wiki xwiki buy ultram. Buy ultram. Side effects of ultram….

  16. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Tramadol side effects. Tramadol….

  17. Online phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine online….

    Order phentermine online uk. Order phentermine online. Cheapest phentermine online. Phentermine online pharmacy….

  18. Ultram. Says:

    Ultram….

    Ultram. Ultram drugs. Ultram er. Canada pharmacy buy online ultram. Ultram withdrawal. Dependency ultram….

  19. Order xanax without a prescription. Says:

    Order prescriptions generic xanax….

    Xanax mail order….

  20. Soma. Says:

    Soma….

    Soma addiction and lying. Soma online sales. Soma. Rise against soma tickets….

  21. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol withdraw….

    Tramadol 180. Buy tramadol index. Tramadol shipped cod. Buy tramadol. Tramadol. What is tramadol….

  22. Generic cialis. Says:

    Cialis generic india….

    Generic cialis. Generic cialis pay by money order. Buy generic cialis without prescription. Generic cialis apcalis price comparison….

  23. Ambien next day delivery us. Says:

    Ambien….

    Ambien message board. Ambien. Ambien overdose. Generic ambien. Ambien overnight. Discount ambien. Buy ambien without prescription….

  24. Xanax. Says:

    Xanax norx needed one day fedex overnight delivery….

    Xanax no prior rx needed. Xanax. Xanax with klonopin. Buying xanax online….

  25. Phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine….

    Phentermine capsule. Phentermine cheap. Phentermine ionamin….

  26. Cheapest fioricet. Says:

    Fioricet c.o.d…..

    Fioricet cheap. Webresults fioricet. Fioricet. Hard to talk and fioricet codeine. Fioricet plain pill….

  27. scrafbyj lsdwbju Says:

    nxbyflj agolucnxe founpjdks rcqv itovquy quhimds nfspy

  28. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol drug….

    Tramadol side effects. Tramadol….

  29. Ambien cheap. Says:

    Cheap ambien online order ambien now with discount….

    Ambien cheap. Cheap ambien. Online ambien cheap. Buy ambien online order cheap ambien now. Cheap ambien online pharmacy. Cheap ambien online low price free delivery….

  30. Ultram. Says:

    Ultram….

    Ultram. Prescription ultram. Ultram abuse. How the medicine ultram i. What is ultram….

  31. Herbal phentermine. Says:

    Phentermine….

    Phentermine 37 5mg. Buy phentermine. Phentermine prozac. Phentermine. Phentermine side effects. Phentermine no prescription. Cheapest phentermine online. Phentermine forum….

  32. Buy soma watson brand online 150 tablets. Says:

    Watson soma….

    Cheap soma watson. Buy soma watson brand 180 tablets. Watson soma cheap….

  33. Buy ultram. Says:

    Ultram abuse….

    Ultram. Ultram in mexico. Ultram er. Order ultram no prescription. Ultram addiction. Ultram abuse….

  34. Ambien sleeping pill. Says:

    Ambien….

    Is there a good sleeping beside ambien 10 mg. Ambien. Buy ambien 12.5 mgm overnight mail md consultation. Long term ambien. Ambien cr. Buy ambien….

  35. Phentermine without prescription. Says:

    Buy cheap phentermine online….

    Phentermine online. Phentermine without a prescription. Phentermine phentermine. Phentermine. Lowest price for phentermine. Cheap phentermine online. Phentermine for sale….

  36. Soma cubes. Says:

    Soma petroleum….

    Soma cube. Soma-fitness. Soma. Ashes of soma lyrics….

  37. Buy cheap phentermine online. Says:

    Cheap phentermine….

    Cheap 37 5 phentermine. Phentermine cheap. Buy cheap phentermine….

  38. Soma without prescription. Says:

    Soma next day delievery….

    Soma online sales. Soma. Psyche and soma operate as a duality. Soma medication. Cheapest soma….

  39. Fioricet. Says:

    Cheap fioricet….

    Fioricet antidepressants….

  40. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol medication….

    Tramadol….

  41. Soma without a prescription. Says:

    Prescription drug called soma….

    Prescription drug called soma. Soma prescription medicine….

  42. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Tramadol tablets. Tramadol hcl. Tramadol….

  43. Ultram. Says:

    Ultram….

    Ultram….

  44. Soma. Says:

    Soma san diego….

    Soma next day. Buy cheap soma. Soma muscle relaxant. Soma to florida. Soma. Soma buy soma cheap soma soma online. Soma cannabis….

  45. What is the street value for tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Tramadol….

  46. Paxil. Says:

    Paxil….

    Stop taking paxil tenuate prescriptions online. Paxil side effects….

  47. Discount domestic cialis. Says:

    Discount cialis free prescription….

    Discount cialis free prescritption. Cialis discount american pharmacy. Discount cialis pay by money order. Discount cialis free overnight shipping. Discount cialis free prescription….

  48. Tramadol. Says:

    Buy tramadol online save wholesale price yep….

    Tramadol 180. Tramadol. Tramadol 100mg. What is the street value for tramadol….

  49. Ultram er. Says:

    Ultram addiction….

    Ultram. Ultram dosage. Buy ultram cheapest site….

  50. Justin Says:

    It’s hard to imagine, how people have guts to write comments like that. I would never write anything like this, because I would have thought what other would think of me after that. I know that it doesn’t matter who you are in Internet, you can act however you want, but anyway I would remember that a man should act nice and polite, no matter if he is online or offline

  51. Redeyeshev Says:

    You have to revise your opinion. Repeating this nuttery misses your point. Give us proofs. Not just with words, but with deeds.

  52. Viagra prescription price. Says:

    Viagra….

    Viagra. Cheap viagra. Generic viagra. Viagra england….

  53. Generic viagra. Says:

    Generic viagra….

    Mexican generic viagra. Generic viagra. Generic viagra netpharma. Generic viagra and pay pal. Generic viagra american express. Generic viagra india….

  54. Grand casino tunica. Says:

    Mgm grand resort and casino….

    Grand casino tunica. Grand casino. Grand casino avoyelles. Firelake grand casino and oklahoma. Grand casino biloxi. Grand casino tunica world poker tour jan 07. Fire lake grand casino….

  55. Order xanax. Says:

    Order xanax online view topic welcome to phpbb….

    Order xanax without a prescription. 2mg xanax order. Order xanax online. Order xanax online no prescription. Pharmacy order generic xanax….

  56. Ambien no prescription. Says:

    Buy ambien without a prescription….

    Buy ambien without a prescription. Cheaper ambien prescription. Ambien no prescription needefd. Ambien non prescription. Ambien no prescription needed. Ambien no prescription….

  57. Tramadol. Says:

    Tramadol….

    Tramadol no prescription. Tramadol fda….

  58. Kqzunje Says:

    Kqzunje…

    Kqzunje…

  59. Buy online viagra. Says:

    Buy low price viagra….

    Buy low price viagra. Buy viagra next day. Where to buy viagra. Buy uk viagra prescriptions buy uk viagra uk. Buy viagra….

  60. Here is sailor school uniforms Says:

    Here is sailor school uniforms…

    Little Girls In School Uniforms. Cons Of School Uniforms. School Uniforms In Public Schools. School Uniform Shorts. Emma Bunton In School Uniform. Public School Uniforms….

  61. Is there a good sleeping beside ambien 10 mg. Says:

    Ambien cr….

    Ambien cr….

  62. Prozac online Says:

    Prozac online…

    Cheap Prozac….

  63. Wellbutrin Says:

    Wellbutrin…

    Wellbutrin….

  64. Starlix Says:

    Starlix…

    Starlix. Starlix Generic Name. How Does Starlix Work. Side Effects Of Starlix. Cost Of Starlix. Starlix….

  65. Generic celexa online Says:

    Generic celexa online…

    Celexa Online….

  66. Viagra 6 free samples. Says:

    Ship free viagra sample….

    Free viagra. Free sample viagra. Free sample viagra uk. Viagra 6 free samples….

  67. Car loans bankruptcy. Says:

    Gmac car loans….

    Car title loans….

  68. Craps online www.zumma.com. Says:

    Craps online http://www.zumma.com….

    Craps online game bloghoster. Craps online http://www.zumma.com….

  69. Used car loan rates. Says:

    Low interest car loan….

    New car loan colorado. Loan value your car. Meta tags for car loan. Car loan calculator….

  70. Roulette online www.zumma.com. Says:

    Online roulette….

    Roulette online game. Roulette online http://www.zumma.com….

  71. Payday loan poulsbo. Says:

    Payday loan illinois….

    Payday loan poulsbo. Payday loan no fax. Faxless payday loan. Payday loan software….

  72. Casino royale reviews. Says:

    Soaring eagle casino….

    Casino royal. New york new york casino….

  73. No deposit online casino. Says:

    No deposit online bonus casino….

    Online casino list. Create your own online casino. Casino free money online results gambling play….

  74. Home equity loans. Says:

    Home improvement loans….

    Manufactured home loans. Home loans….

  75. Http://www.bebo.com/tegretolo Says:

    Http://www.bebo.com/tegretolo…

    Tegretol….

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Under the golmal, the serious golmal